How to Write the 7LMS2116 Critical Theoretical Commentary (Coursework 1, Herts)
A strong 7LMS2116 commentary does not summarise your chosen text; it puts the text on trial. In 2,500 words you need to explain the author’s argument accurately, set it against competing perspectives in International Relations, test it with at least twelve scholarly sources and finish with a clear judgement of its contribution. Markers reward evaluation, so spend your words on weighing the argument rather than retelling it.
If you would like a second opinion on your choice of text or your structure, our international relations and politics assignment help page explains the support available.
What the coursework is really asking
The 7LMS2116 Puzzles and Paradigms in International Relations Coursework 1 brief at the University of Hertfordshire is a Level 7 critical theoretical commentary worth 100% of the module. You choose one of six topics, each with a listed key source, and the word limit is 2,500 words with a 10% tolerance, including footnotes and references but excluding the bibliography. Submission is on Friday 15 January 2027 at 23:59 through Canvas.
The brief names four things the marker will look at: structure and communication, engagement with the literature, critical evaluation of arguments, and a reasoned judgement about the source’s significance. The key source is the starting point, not the whole answer.
The six source options at a glance
| Topic | Listed source | Core question to test |
|---|---|---|
| Gender | Enloe, “Gender Makes the World Go Round: Where are the Women?” | Does a gender lens change what counts as international politics? |
| Race | Zvobgo and Loken, “Why Race is Critical to the Field of International Relations” | How far has the discipline ignored race, and what follows from that? |
| Religion and culture | Huntington, “The Clash of Civilizations?” | Is culture the main source of post-Cold War conflict? |
| Environment | Brown, Hammill and McLeman, “Climate Change as the ‘New’ Security Threat: Implications for Africa” | Should climate change be treated as a security issue? |
| Technology | Drezner, “Technological Change and International Relations” | Does technology reshape the international system or only intensify existing patterns? |
| Subaltern perspectives | Spivak, “Can the Subaltern Speak?” | Whose voices does International Relations theory leave out? |
Pick the source where you can find a real academic argument about the text, not just material that agrees with it. A source with well-known critics, such as Huntington, gives you ready-made debate. A newer source may be easier to understand but harder to set against rival views.
Want to see the shape of a finished answer first? Our 7LMS2116 Huntington commentary sample is for information and reference only, and its word split is labelled illustrative.
How to structure 2,500 words
The brief’s guiding questions map neatly onto a structure. A suggested split follows, which you should adjust to your own argument.
| Section | Suggested words | What it must do |
|---|---|---|
| Introduction | 200 | State your judgement of the source in the first paragraph and outline the route |
| The key argument | 450 | Explain the author’s thesis, assumptions and conclusions accurately and briefly |
| The academic debate | 600 | Place the source among competing theoretical perspectives |
| Evaluation with wider literature | 900 | Show how other scholars support, challenge, refine or extend the argument |
| Judgement and conclusion | 350 | Give a reasoned verdict on contribution and significance |
Because the word count includes footnotes, long explanatory footnotes eat into your limit. Keep them short and use them for citations, not for extra argument.
Make the commentary critical, not descriptive
Many weak commentaries spend most of their length describing the text. A better approach is to ask three questions of every paragraph. What does this source claim? Who disagrees, and why? What does the evidence suggest? If a paragraph answers only the first, it is probably descriptive.
For a text like Huntington’s, for example, the debate runs between realist and liberal explanations of conflict, constructivist accounts of identity, quantitative tests of the thesis, and postcolonial critiques of treating cultures as fixed blocs. The same logic applies to other options. Each of the six sources has supporters, critics and later work that extends it, and your job is to put them in conversation.
Your judgement should be earned by the analysis. Phrases such as “the argument is persuasive but narrow” work only if the preceding sections show why. Link back to the module’s theoretical frameworks, because the learning outcomes ask you to connect theory to real-world events and to the epistemological and ontological assumptions behind different approaches.
For help shaping an evaluative argument of this kind, our critical review writing help page is a useful next step.
Choosing and using twelve sources
The brief expects engagement with at least twelve relevant academic sources, and says quality and relevance matter more than quantity. In practice that means a mix.
- The key source itself, read closely, including any later book or reply by the same author.
- Two or three works that frame the wider debate, such as major rival theories.
- Four or five studies that test, critique or extend the argument, including empirical work where it exists.
- One or two sources that connect the argument to a real-world case or event.
Prefer peer-reviewed journal articles and scholarly books over websites and summaries. Check every reference against the Politics and International Relations Referencing Guide on Canvas, because footnote style is easy to get wrong.
A worked outline using Huntington
Suppose you choose the Huntington option. Your opening judgement might be that the article is a valuable provocation but a weak explanation of conflict. The argument section would cover his claim that cultural identity becomes the main source of conflict after the Cold War. The debate section would place it against realist and liberal accounts and constructivist readings of identity. The evaluation section would bring in empirical tests of the thesis and critiques that accuse it of treating civilizations as fixed and uniform. The conclusion would then weigh what the article contributed against what it failed to explain. The same skeleton works for any of the six sources if you swap in the relevant debates.
Mark-maximising checklist
- A clear judgement of the source in the introduction, not saved for the end.
- An accurate, compact account of the author’s argument and assumptions.
- At least twelve relevant scholarly sources, each doing analytical work.
- Competing perspectives set against each other, not listed one after another.
- Strengths, limitations and implications of the argument all covered.
- A conclusion that answers the question of contribution and significance.
- Footnotes and references in the style required by the Canvas guide.
- An accurate word count stated at the end, within the 10% tolerance.
- The AI declaration on the front page, and no name or student number anywhere.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Summarising the whole article instead of the argument that matters for your evaluation.
- Treating the key source as the only source, when the brief expects wider literature.
- Listing critics without saying which side is more convincing and why.
- Using broad textbook summaries in place of specific scholarly arguments.
- Letting footnotes grow until they use up the word limit.
- Using generative AI to produce content, which the brief does not permit, or using it for proofreading without declaring it.
Where students usually get stuck
Most students find the first step hardest: choosing a source and a line of argument. Try writing your judgement in two sentences before you start, then see which sources support it and which push against it. If the sources push against your first view, that is useful, because a revised judgement is usually stronger than the original.
A second difficulty is balance. Twelve sources and 2,500 words leave little room, so give each source a job. Another is time: late work at Level 7 loses 10 grade points a day until the grade reaches 50, so plan backwards from the January deadline and leave a few days for editing.
For help with structure and referencing, our report writing help page is another route, and you can browse more University of Hertfordshire assignment briefs.
FAQs
How many sources do I need for 7LMS2116 Coursework 1?
The brief expects at least twelve relevant academic sources. Quality and relevance matter more than the number, so every source should do real analytical work.
Can I use the module’s lecture material as well?
Yes. The brief allows you to draw on concepts and debates from elsewhere in the module where appropriate, as long as the selected source stays central to the analysis.
Do footnotes count towards the 2,500 words?
Yes. The word limit includes footnotes and references but excludes the bibliography, with a 10% tolerance either way. State an accurate word count at the end.
Which of the six sources is the easiest?
None is easy, but a source with a long critical literature gives you more debate to work with. Choose the one where you can build a clear argument about its strengths and limits.
Is generative AI allowed?
No, not to create content. The brief permits AI only for proofreading, and any such use must be declared on the front page.
What happens if I submit late?
At Level 7, late work loses 10 grade points per day until the grade reaches 50. The deadline is Friday 15 January 2027 at 23:59 on Canvas, so check the portal in good time.
If you are short of time before the deadline, send your details through our submit assignment page and we will advise on the next step, or read about us to see how we work.




