How to Write the NS5203 Evidence Based Research Critical Review at UEL
An NS5203 critical review scores well when it picks one narrow area of nursing practice, shows a repeatable literature search, appraises at least two review articles with a recognised framework such as CASP, and ends with recommendations that follow directly from the evidence. The 2,000 words are tight, so every section needs a job. This guide explains how to plan each part, where marks are usually lost and what to check before you submit.
If you want a second opinion on your topic or draft, our nursing assignment help page explains the support available.
What the assessment is really asking
The NS5203 Evidence Based Research critical review brief at the University of East London asks you to analyse an aspect of clinical practice or a service, explain why it exists, test it against the best available evidence and propose improvements. The task is not a general essay about a health condition. It is a focused evaluation of one practice and its effect on the quality of care.
The brief sets a 2,000-word limit with a 10% margin, a Harvard reference list of 12 to 15 sources and a submission through Moodle. Always confirm the deadline and file rules in your own module area, because those details can change between cohorts.
How to split the 2,000 words
| Section | Approx. words | What it must do |
|---|---|---|
| Introduction and search strategy | 300 | Justify the topic, state the focus, report databases, search terms and limits |
| Background to current practice | 300 | Describe what is done now, why, and what national guidance says |
| Area to be improved | 300 | Name one gap and justify it with policy and research |
| Literature review and critical analysis | 900 | Appraise two or more reviews, compare methods and findings |
| Recommendations and conclusion | 200 | Give actions, expected effect on patients and service delivery |
The literature section carries nearly half the words, so it usually carries most of the marks. Spending 600 words on background and leaving 300 for the analysis is the most common planning error.
Choose a topic that is narrow enough
A good topic has a clear clinical setting, a defined patient group and at least two published systematic reviews. Falls prevention in older inpatients, pressure ulcer prevention, early warning scores, hydration in care homes and nurse-led discharge planning all fit that pattern. A topic such as mental health in general does not, because the reviews you find will answer different questions.
Test your topic by writing one focused question in a single sentence. If you cannot say who, what practice and what outcome, narrow it again before searching. You can see how one topic is handled in our NS5203 falls prevention reference sample, which is for information and reference only.
Make the search strategy transparent
Markers look for a search they could repeat. Name the databases, such as CINAHL, MEDLINE, PsycINFO and the Cochrane Library. List the search terms, the Boolean operators and any truncation. State the limits, for example English language, publication from 2015 and adult patients. Add brief inclusion and exclusion criteria, and say why you excluded certain types of study.
A small table or a short paragraph is enough. If you used a PRISMA-style flow of records identified, screened and included, a simple figure can show it quickly, but do not spend many words explaining it.
Appraise, do not summarise
The most common mistake is to describe what each review found and stop. Critical appraisal means judging how far the findings can be trusted. The CASP checklist for systematic reviews gives you a ready structure, because it asks about the focus of the question, the search, the inclusion of relevant studies, quality assessment, the combining of results and local applicability.
A short comparison table helps you stay within the word count and makes the analysis visible.
| Appraisal point | Question to ask of each review |
|---|---|
| Question and design | Was the question focused, and was the review registered or protocol-led? |
| Search | Which databases and dates, and could relevant studies have been missed? |
| Quality of included studies | Were randomised and non-randomised studies mixed, and was risk of bias reported? |
| Results | How large is the effect, how precise is it, and how certain is the evidence? |
| Applicability | Would the setting, staffing and patients match your own area? |
After the table, compare the two reviews directly. Where they agree, say so and note that agreement from independent teams strengthens confidence. Where they disagree, explain whether the cause is different inclusion criteria, different outcomes or different dates of search.
Link every recommendation to evidence and guidance
Recommendations should not appear from nowhere. Each one should trace back to a finding in your analysis and, where possible, to NICE guidance or another national source. Keep them practical: what a ward, a team or a service could change, who would be responsible and how you would know it worked. Mention patient outcomes and service delivery, since the brief names both.
Remember confidentiality. If you draw on your own placement, use pseudonyms and leave out any detail that could identify a patient, a colleague or a unit.
Mark-maximising checklist
- One focused question stated in the introduction.
- Search strategy with databases, terms, Boolean operators, limits and criteria.
- At least two review articles appraised with CASP or another named framework.
- A direct comparison of the two reviews, not two separate summaries.
- National guidance or policy used in the background and the recommendations.
- Recommendations tied to findings, with a note on outcomes for patients and the service.
- Harvard references that match the in-text citations, with 12 to 15 sources.
- Word count within the allowed margin, and format as the brief states.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Choosing a topic so broad that no two reviews answer the same question.
- Reporting the search as a sentence (“I searched PubMed”) with no terms or limits.
- Describing study results without judging their quality.
- Relying on single trials or narrative articles when the brief asks for review articles.
- Writing recommendations that are generic, such as “more training is needed”.
- Leaving out the practice context, so the reader cannot see why the issue matters.
- Citing sources that do not appear in the reference list, or the reverse.
Pain points students tell us about
Many nursing students struggle to find review articles that match their topic closely. If your first search returns hundreds of records, narrow the population or the setting rather than reading more abstracts. Others find the CASP wording hard to apply, so work through the questions in order and write one short judgement for each. A third problem is time: the module runs alongside placements, so aim to finish the search and the appraisal table before you draft any prose.
For help with the structure of a literature section, our literature review writing support page is a useful next step, and our about us page explains how we work.
FAQs
Which databases should I search for NS5203?
CINAHL, MEDLINE, PsycINFO and the Cochrane Library are the usual choices for nursing topics. Use at least two, and report them with the dates you searched.
Can I use a framework other than CASP?
Yes, the brief allows other frameworks. Choose one designed for your study type, apply it consistently to both reviews and name it in the text.
How many reviews do I need to appraise?
The brief asks for at least two key review articles. Two well-chosen reviews appraised in depth usually beat four described briefly.
Should I include a PRISMA flow diagram?
A simple flow of records found, screened and included can support your search strategy. It is optional unless your module team says otherwise, so check your brief and any tutor guidance.
Can I write about my own placement?
You can use your placement to choose the topic, but you must protect confidentiality. Use pseudonyms and avoid anything that identifies a patient, staff member or organisation.
Is a reference sample allowed as a study aid?
Reference samples are a legitimate way to see structure. Follow your university’s academic integrity rules and submit work that reflects your own reading and judgement.
If you are short of time before the deadline, send your details through our submit assignment page and we will advise on the next step, or explore our healthcare assignment help for related support.




