7LMS2116 Coursework 1 Sample: Huntington Critical Theoretical Commentary (Model Answer Extract)

For information and reference only – not to be submitted as your own work.

This extract shows one way to approach the 7LMS2116 Puzzles and Paradigms in International Relations Coursework 1 brief at the University of Hertfordshire, which asks for a 2,500-word critical theoretical commentary on one listed source. It takes option C, Huntington’s “The Clash of Civilizations?”, and is condensed, so the word split below is illustrative. Our guide on how to write the 7LMS2116 critical theoretical commentary explains the thinking behind each section. Your own brief, the Canvas referencing guide and your tutor’s instructions set the rules you must follow.

Planning table

Brief requirement Suggested words (illustrative) What the marker looks for
Key argument 450 An accurate, compact account of the thesis, not a summary of the whole article
Academic debate 600 Realist, liberal and constructivist readings set against the source
Evaluation with wider literature 900 Evidence and critiques that support, challenge or refine the argument
Judgement 350 A clear verdict on contribution and significance
Referencing and word count Applied throughout At least twelve relevant sources, accurate citations and an honest word count

1. Introduction: putting the text on trial

Huntington (1993) argued that after the Cold War the fundamental source of conflict in world politics would be cultural rather than ideological or economic. Nation states would remain the main actors, but “fault lines” between civilizations would become the battle lines of the future. This commentary argues that the article is more valuable as a provocation than as an explanation. Its attention to identity reshaped the post-Cold War debate, yet the evidence for its central claim is weak and its picture of civilizations is too fixed to support the policy conclusions it invites.

The commentary first sets out the argument, then places it within realist, liberal and constructivist debates, tests it against empirical and critical literature, and ends with a judgement.

2. The key argument

Huntington (1993) defined a civilization as the broadest cultural grouping of people, formed by language, history, religion, customs and institutions as well as self-identification. He identified several major civilizations, including Western, Confucian, Japanese, Islamic, Hindu, Slavic-Orthodox and Latin American, and possibly African. Four claims carry the thesis. Civilizational differences are basic and slow to change. The world is becoming smaller, which increases awareness of difference. Economic modernisation and the weakening of the nation state as a source of identity push people towards religion and civilization. Finally, cultural characteristics are harder to compromise on than political or economic ones.

From these premises Huntington predicted that conflicts would increasingly occur along the borders between civilizations, and that “kin-country” loyalty would draw states into disputes beyond their own borders. He also framed the West as facing a wider challenge from other civilizations, especially Islamic and Confucian ones. The 1996 book developed the argument into a model of world order with core states for each civilization, and removed the question mark from the title (Huntington, 1996).

The thesis matters for the module because it makes a claim about what drives international politics, not only a forecast. It tells policymakers where to look for danger, which is why its premises deserve close testing.

3. The wider debate

3.1 Against the end of history

Huntington’s article is best read against Fukuyama (1992), who argued that liberal democracy had won the contest of ideas and that large ideological struggle was ending. Huntington accepted that the ideological contest between East and West had ended, but denied that it would produce convergence. For him, the end of one source of conflict simply exposed another. Read together, the two works frame the post-Cold War debate: one expects convergence, the other expects cultural division.

3.2 Realist and liberal responses

Realists would accept Huntington’s focus on states and power but reject culture as the engine of conflict. On this view, disputes arise from the structure of an anarchic system, and cultural labels are used to rationalise interests. Liberals instead point to democracy and economic interdependence as the factors that make war less likely. Russett, Oneal and Cox (2000) tested these rival accounts directly. Using data on militarised interstate disputes for 1950 to 1992, they found that realist variables such as contiguity, alliances and relative power, together with liberal variables such as joint democracy and trade, explained conflict much better than civilizational differences. States divided by civilizational lines were no more likely to fight, and only conflict within the West was significantly less likely.

Constructivists offer a more sympathetic but still critical reading. They accept that identities and norms shape state behaviour, which is the strongest part of Huntington’s insight. They would, however, treat civilizations as socially constructed and contested rather than as given blocs. That difference is central to the critique in section 4.

If you are unsure which of the six listed texts suits your strengths, our submit assignment page is the quickest way to ask for guidance on your own choice.

4. Testing and criticising the argument

4.1 The empirical record

The quantitative literature is largely unfavourable to the thesis. Henderson and Tucker (2001) analysed interstate war from 1816 to 1992. They found no significant link between civilization membership and war onset in the Cold War years or in the early post-Cold War period, and found that states of similar civilizations were more likely to fight before 1945. Chiozza (2002), examining conflict involvement from 1946 to 1997, concluded that interactions across civilizational lines were not more conflict-prone and that the first post-Cold War years did not support Huntington. Fox (2005) turned to domestic conflict, using the Minorities at Risk and State Failure datasets, and found that civilizational conflicts were less common than non-civilizational ones and did not become more violent after the Cold War.

These studies use different datasets and definitions, which is a point for the commentary rather than a weakness: the pattern is consistent across interstate and intrastate evidence. Defenders could argue that the studies measure conflict too narrowly, because Huntington was concerned with identity and perception as well as battle deaths. That is a fair reply, but it also makes the thesis harder to test, and a thesis that is difficult to falsify has less explanatory value.

4.2 Essentialism and power

The sharpest conceptual criticism comes from Said (2001), who argued that Huntington treats “Islam” and “the West” as sealed, unified blocs. Said pointed to the internal diversity of each, to the long history of exchange between them and to the presence of Muslim communities inside Western societies. He also argued that the clash framing was used after 11 September 2001 to turn a criminal act by a small group into evidence of civilizational war. His alternative was to focus on power, politics and universal standards of justice rather than large cultural abstractions.

This critique exposes a weak assumption in Huntington’s premises. If civilizations are internally plural and constantly changing, the claim that cultural difference produces predictable conflict loses much of its force. It also raises a normative problem: a prediction that shapes how policymakers see others can contribute to the conflict it describes. Fox (2005) makes a similar warning, suggesting that the prediction could only come true if it became self-fulfilling.

4.3 What the argument still explains

Three strengths remain. First, the article took identity, religion and culture seriously at a time when mainstream theory said little about them, and it anticipated the later growth of work on these themes. Second, it recognised that the end of the Cold War would not remove conflict from world politics. Third, its emphasis on the role of religion in public life proved more durable than its theory of state behaviour. These strengths concern the questions it raised, not the accuracy of its answers.

4.4 Applying the argument to a case

A strong commentary tests the thesis against a real episode rather than only against datasets. The wars that followed the break-up of Yugoslavia in the 1990s are the obvious choice, because Huntington treated the region as a fault line between Western, Orthodox and Islamic civilizations. A critical reading would ask whether religion and culture caused the violence or were mobilised by political leaders competing for power in a collapsing state. If the second reading is more convincing, the case supports the constructivist and power-based critiques instead of the civilizational thesis. Whichever way you argue, you need sources that engage with the case directly, and the brief expects you to show how scholars support, challenge or refine the argument, so the case should be used to sharpen the evaluation, not to add description.

5. Judgement

Huntington’s article is a significant intervention but a weak theory. Its contribution was to widen the field of vision of International Relations to include culture and identity, and this explains why it continues to be taught and criticised. Its limitations are serious. The evidence reviewed above does not support the claim that civilizational difference is the main source of conflict, the categories are too coarse to capture internal variety, and the framing carries political risks. Realist and liberal accounts explain more of the observed pattern, while constructivist and postcolonial critiques explain better why the thesis has proved so influential. The most defensible position is therefore to value the source for the debates it started, and to treat its causal claims with caution.

If you need a tailored response for your own chosen text, our international relations and politics assignment help and critical review writing help pages explain what we can do. You can also browse more University of Hertfordshire assignment briefs, or see how a different discipline handles critical evaluation in our critical review sample and legal commentary sample.

References

Chiozza, G. (2002) ‘Is there a clash of civilizations? Evidence from patterns of international conflict involvement, 1946–97’, Journal of Peace Research, 39(6), pp. 711–734.

Fox, J. (2005) ‘Paradigm lost: Huntington’s unfulfilled clash of civilizations prediction into the 21st century’, International Politics, 42(4), pp. 428–457.

Fukuyama, F. (1992) The end of history and the last man. New York: Free Press.

Henderson, E.A. and Tucker, R. (2001) ‘Clear and present strangers: the clash of civilizations and international conflict’, International Studies Quarterly, 45(2), pp. 317–338.

Huntington, S.P. (1993) ‘The clash of civilizations?’, Foreign Affairs, 72(3), pp. 22–49.

Huntington, S.P. (1996) The clash of civilizations and the remaking of world order. New York: Simon & Schuster.

Russett, B.M., Oneal, J.R. and Cox, M. (2000) ‘Clash of civilizations, or realism and liberalism déjà vu? Some evidence’, Journal of Peace Research, 37(5), pp. 583–608.

Said, E.W. (2001) ‘The clash of ignorance’, The Nation, 22 October. Available at: https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/clash-ignorance/ (Accessed: 21 November 2026).

Prepared by
Students Assignment Help UK Editorial Team

Students Assignment Help UK Editorial Team

This model answer was prepared by our editorial team in response to a real assignment brief we received. It shows one way to approach the task and is meant as a study guide, not for submission.

do you want plagiarism free & researched assignment solution!

UPTO 35% DISCOUNT

Get Your Assignment Completed At Lower Prices

Plagiarism Free Solutions
100% Original Work
24*7 Online Assistance
Native PhD Experts
Hire a Writer Now

Facing Issues with Assignments? Talk to Our Experts Now!Download Our App Now!

Have Questions About Our Services?
Download Our App!

Get the App Today!

QRcode