NS5203 Evidence Based Research Critical Review Sample: Falls Prevention on Acute Wards | University of East London

For information and reference only – not to be submitted as your own work.

This extract shows one way to build a response to the NS5203 Evidence Based Research critical review brief at the University of East London. It uses inpatient falls prevention on adult acute wards as an illustrative practice area and appraises two published systematic reviews with the CASP checklist. Our guide on how to plan the NS5203 critical review explains the thinking behind each section. Your own brief sets the word limit, the number of sources and the referencing rules, so check it before borrowing any structure.

Planning table

Section Suggested words What the marker looks for
Introduction and search strategy 300 A narrow topic, a reason it matters to nursing, and a search another person could repeat
Background to current practice 300 What is done now and why, with national data and guidance
Area to be improved 300 One specific gap, justified with policy and research
Critical analysis of two reviews 900 A framework used properly, findings compared, limits stated
Recommendations and conclusion 200 Actions that follow from the evidence, linked to patient outcomes
References Not counted Harvard (Cite Them Right) and a mix of reviews, guidance and checklists

Buy Non Plagiarized & Properly Structured Assignment Solution

Introduction and search strategy

Falls are the most common patient safety incident reported in acute hospitals in England. NHS Improvement (2017) estimated that around 250,000 inpatient falls were reported in English hospitals in a year, with an average cost to trusts of about £2,600 per fall. Falls cause distress, injury, longer stays and loss of confidence, so prevention sits close to the core of nursing care. This review examines multifactorial and single-component falls prevention for older adults on acute wards, and asks which parts of current practice are supported by systematic review evidence.

The search was run in CINAHL, MEDLINE and the Cochrane Library, with PubMed used to check citations. The illustrative Boolean string was (fall* OR “accidental fall*”) AND (prevent* OR reduc* OR intervention*) AND (hospital* OR inpatient* OR “acute care”) AND (“systematic review” OR “meta-analysis”). Limits were English language, 2015 onwards, and adult inpatients. Reviews were included if they synthesised trials of hospital falls interventions and reported falls outcomes. Reviews limited to care homes, community settings or paediatric wards were excluded. Two reviews were chosen for appraisal because they were recent, methodologically explicit and directly relevant to wards: Cameron et al. (2018) and Morris et al. (2022).

Background to current practice

Most acute trusts use a risk screen on admission, an individual care plan, and a bundle of measures such as call-bell checks, footwear review, medication review and supervised mobilisation. National guidance supports multifactorial assessment: NICE (2025) sets out assessment and prevention of falls in older people and in people aged 50 and over at higher risk. The Royal College of Physicians (2017) audit of inpatient falls reported that hospitals were improving on some process measures, but that gaps remained in some basic checks.

The rationale for the bundle approach is that falls have several causes, including delirium, urgency, sedating medicines and unfamiliar environments. The main limitation is that a bundle is hard to deliver consistently when wards are short-staffed. Practice before and after a bundle is introduced can look very different on paper, so the quality of the evidence for each element matters. Where a ward relies on a scored risk tool alone, there is also a risk that staff treat the score as the intervention.

Area of practice to be improved

The area chosen for improvement is how far the elements of a falls bundle are supported by review-level evidence, and in particular whether patient and staff education should receive more emphasis than equipment. Sensor alarms, low beds and similar devices are widely used because they are visible and easy to audit. If the evidence for them is weak, effort and money may be diverted from approaches that work better. The gap is a clinical one, since bedside nurses make daily decisions about which measures to prioritise, and a policy one, because national guidance and local audit tools tend to count what is easy to count.

Critical analysis of the two reviews

Both reviews were appraised with the CASP systematic review checklist (CASP, 2018), which asks whether the question was focused, whether the right studies were sought and included, whether quality was assessed, whether results were combined appropriately, and whether the findings apply locally.

CASP area Cameron et al. (2018) Morris et al. (2022)
Focused question and design Cochrane review of randomised trials of falls prevention in care facilities and hospitals Systematic review and meta-analysis of hospital falls interventions, registered on PROSPERO
Search and inclusion Searches to August 2017; 95 trials; 24 hospital trials with 97,790 participants Seven databases to May 2021; 45 studies, 23 in the meta-analyses; randomised and non-randomised designs
Quality assessment Risk of bias and certainty of evidence graded for each comparison Risk of bias reported; certainty of evidence graded by intervention
Main hospital findings Multifactorial interventions: rate ratio 0.80 (95% CI 0.64 to 1.01), low certainty; subacute settings 0.67 (0.54 to 0.83) Education: rate ratio 0.70 (0.51 to 0.96); multifactorial: 0.80 (0.63 to 1.01)
Main limitation Evidence for most hospital interventions was low or very low certainty Injury outcomes could not be pooled because definitions differed

Cameron et al. (2018) is the stronger review on methods. It follows Cochrane procedures, restricts itself to randomised trials, and grades certainty for each comparison. Its hospital findings are cautious. Multifactorial interventions reduced the rate of falls by about one fifth, but the confidence interval touched no effect, and the certainty was low. A benefit was clearer in subacute wards, which suggests that case mix and length of stay may shape what works. Sensor alarms showed a similar rate ratio of 0.60 but with a very wide interval (0.27 to 1.34) and very low certainty, so the evidence neither supports nor rules out benefit.

Morris et al. (2022) is more recent and includes non-randomised studies, which widens the evidence base but raises the risk of confounding. The authors found that patient and staff education was the intervention category with a statistically significant pooled reduction in falls rate. The multifactorial result mirrors Cameron et al.: the same point estimate of 0.80 and an interval that only just includes 1. The consistency between two independent reviews strengthens confidence that multifactorial care probably helps a little, even if neither review proves it.

The reviews differ in ways that matter for the question. Cameron et al. pooled trials into broad intervention groups, while Morris et al. split education, assistive devices, environment and rehabilitation into separate analyses. Neither found pooled evidence that environmental changes or assistive devices reduce falls. Both note heterogeneity in how interventions were delivered, so a pooled estimate may hide the difference between a well-run bundle and a poorly implemented one. Injury outcomes, which matter most to patients, were reported less consistently than falls counts. Applicability to a UK ward is reasonable, as the included trials span several health systems, though staffing and delirium rates will vary locally.

Taken together, the reviews suggest that practice has leaned towards equipment more than the evidence justifies. They also show that absence of proof is not proof of absence, because many comparisons were underpowered. A critical reader should therefore avoid both overstating the benefit of education and dismissing devices altogether.

Recommendations and conclusion

First, wards should keep multifactorial assessment as the core of practice, as NICE (2025) recommends, while recognising that its measured effect is modest. Second, patient and staff education should be planned deliberately, for example short bedside conversations about calling for help and structured staff teaching, rather than treated as a leaflet. Third, equipment such as sensor alarms should be used for defined reasons and reviewed, not as a default. Fourth, audits should track falls with harm as well as falls per 1,000 bed days, so improvement is judged on outcomes patients notice. Finally, a pilot on one ward with before and after data would give local evidence, using pseudonyms and no identifiable patient detail.

In conclusion, two recent systematic reviews point the same way: multifactorial care and education have the best support in hospitals, while the evidence for many popular devices is uncertain. Nurses can use this to prioritise time at the bedside, and future research should report injurious falls consistently.

If you need a tailored response on your own practice area, our nursing assignment help and literature review writing support pages explain what we can do, and you can browse more University of East London assignment briefs. For a related appraisal exercise, see our sample critique of two research papers.

Please Write Fresh Non Plagiarized Assignment on this Topic

References

Cameron, I.D., Dyer, S.M., Panagoda, C.E., Murray, G.R., Hill, K.D., Cumming, R.G. and Kerse, N. (2018) ‘Interventions for preventing falls in older people in care facilities and hospitals’, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, (9), CD005465. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD005465.pub4.

Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (2018) CASP systematic review checklist. Available at: https://casp-uk.net/casp-tools-checklists/systematic-reviews-meta-analysis-rcts/ (Accessed: 16 November 2026).

Morris, M.E., Webster, K., Jones, C., Hill, A.-M., Haines, T., McPhail, S., Kiegaldie, D., Slade, S., Jazayeri, D., Heng, H., Shorr, R., Carey, L., Barker, A. and Cameron, I. (2022) ‘Interventions to reduce falls in hospitals: a systematic review and meta-analysis’, Age and Ageing, 51(5), afac077.

National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (2025) Falls: assessment and prevention in older people and in people 50 and over at higher risk. NICE guideline NG249. London: NICE.

NHS Improvement (2017) The incidence and costs of inpatient falls in hospitals. London: NHS Improvement.

Royal College of Physicians (2017) National Audit of Inpatient Falls: audit report 2017. London: RCP.

Prepared by
Students Assignment Help UK Editorial Team

Students Assignment Help UK Editorial Team

This model answer was prepared by our editorial team in response to a real assignment brief we received. It shows one way to approach the task and is meant as a study guide, not for submission.

do you want plagiarism free & researched assignment solution!

UPTO 35% DISCOUNT

Get Your Assignment Completed At Lower Prices

Plagiarism Free Solutions
100% Original Work
24*7 Online Assistance
Native PhD Experts
Hire a Writer Now

Facing Issues with Assignments? Talk to Our Experts Now!Download Our App Now!

Have Questions About Our Services?
Download Our App!

Get the App Today!

QRcode