7FNCE015W Commercial Lending Project Model Answer: £60,000 Start-Up Loan Appraisal (Westminster)
For information and reference only – not to be submitted as your own work.
This extract shows one way to approach the 7FNCE015W Global Banking and Lending Assessment 2 commercial lending project at the University of Westminster, written from the viewpoint of a bank lending officer. The case summary gives the structure of the funding but not every projection, so the cash-flow figures below are illustrative and must be replaced with the numbers in your own case pack. For the planning logic behind each part, read our guide on how to write a commercial lending appraisal report. Check your own brief for the report format, appendix rules and the generative AI declaration.
Planning table
| Question | Marks | What the lending officer must show |
|---|---|---|
| (a) Is the £60,000 loan a good risk? | 30 | A structured credit appraisal of character, management, market, purpose and financial strength |
| (b) Will the project run short of finance? | 23 | Monthly cash flow, sensitivity testing and the timing of the £100,000 risk capital |
| (c) How easily will repayment be achieved? | 22 | Instalment size, coverage of debt service and the sources of repayment |
| (d) What security should be requested? | 13 | Realistic security matched to a business with few tangible assets |
| (e) Presentation and research | 12 | Theory applied to the case, appendix calculations and referencing |
(a) Is a £60,000 loan a good risk proposition?
A credit officer starts with a framework, because it stops the analysis from becoming a list of opinions. The CAMPARI headings (character, ability, means, purpose, amount, repayment and insurance) or the 5 Cs give a clean structure. Applied to this case, the appraisal reads as follows.
| Heading | Evidence in the case | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
| Character and management | An experienced entrepreneur supported by media advertising and distribution partners | Positive, but references and a track record should be verified |
| Ability and market | A new monthly title for young adults and families interested in biking and travel, sold through national outlets at £2.50 | Crowded niche; advertising income and sale-or-return returns are the key uncertainties |
| Means (owner’s stake) | £25,000 equity against a £60,000 loan | Debt is 2.4 times equity, or 70.6% of total funding, which is highly geared |
| Purpose | Production and trading costs of the first issues | Legitimate, but working capital loans fund losses rather than assets |
| Repayment | Two-year term; turnover forecast to exceed £1 million by year four | Repayment falls before the business matures, so it depends on early sales |
| Insurance and security | Few tangible assets | Needs a guarantee and a charge over the company |
The bank’s key concern is that profit and cash are different. A start-up publisher has to print, distribute and promote each issue before it is paid, so it is vulnerable to timing gaps. Altman’s (1968) work on failure prediction is a useful reminder that low liquidity and weak retained earnings are the typical features of young businesses that fail. The proposal is therefore a conditional lending proposition rather than a clear yes: the management case is credible, but the gearing and early cash timing are weak.
(b) Is the project likely to run short of finance?
The test is a monthly cash flow, not the profit forecast. The table below uses illustrative figures to show how to present the argument. It assumes year-one net sales receipts of £240,000, direct costs at 75% of sales and overheads of £108,000, with the loan repaid in 24 equal monthly instalments at an illustrative 9% a year. That gives an instalment of £2,741 and annual debt service of £32,893.
| Year-one cash (illustrative) | Base case (£) | Sales 10% lower (£) |
|---|---|---|
| Net sales receipts | 240,000 | 216,000 |
| Direct costs (75% of sales) | (180,000) | (162,000) |
| Overheads | (108,000) | (108,000) |
| Operating cash flow | (48,000) | (54,000) |
| Equity and loan received | 85,000 | 85,000 |
| Loan repayments (12 instalments) | (32,893) | (32,893) |
| Closing cash | 4,107 | (1,893) |
Even in the base case the company ends the year with about £4,000, which is under two weeks of overheads. A 10% sales shortfall pushes it into a £1,893 deficit, so an overdraft or extra funding request is likely. The £100,000 of risk capital, for which a 31.25% shareholding is offered, would imply a post-money value of £320,000 (£100,000 ÷ 0.3125). If it arrives late or in part, the funding gap appears in the first year. The officer should therefore make drawdown conditional on that equity being committed, not just promised.
Our banking and finance assignment support page explains how we can check ratios and cash flows like these.
Buy Non Plagiarized & Properly Structured Assignment Solution
(c) How easily will repayment be achieved?
Repayment capacity is measured by the debt service coverage ratio: operating cash flow before financing divided by annual loan repayments. Using illustrative year-two figures of £600,000 receipts, direct costs of £450,000 and overheads of £120,000, operating cash flow is £30,000.
| Measure (illustrative) | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly instalment | £60,000 at 9% a year over 24 months | £2,741 |
| Total repaid | £2,741 × 24 | about £65,786, including £5,786 interest |
| Year-two debt service cover | £30,000 ÷ £32,893 | 0.91 times |
| Cover after opening cash | (£30,000 + £4,107) ÷ £32,893 | 1.04 times |
A cover ratio below one means the business cannot repay from trading alone. Many lenders look for at least 1.25 times, so this profile would not pass without the second equity round or a longer term. The recommendation is to restructure rather than refuse: extend the term to three years to lower the instalment, or agree a capital repayment holiday in the first months while the title builds its readership. Both reduce the early pressure but increase total interest, which the officer should disclose to the borrower.
(d) What security should the bank request?
Berger and Udell (1990) found that collateral is more common for riskier borrowers, which fits a start-up with weak financials. In this case the company has few tangible assets, so the usual property charge is unavailable. The realistic package has four elements:
- Debenture. A fixed and floating charge over the company’s assets, including receivables and any equipment or intellectual property.
- Personal guarantee. From the lead entrepreneur, limited to a stated amount, with independent legal advice recorded.
- Key person insurance. Assigned to the bank, because the business depends on its founder.
- Covenants. Monthly management accounts, a minimum cash balance and consent before further borrowing.
The Enterprise Investment Scheme also matters. It offers tax reliefs to investors in qualifying companies, so it may help the company attract the £100,000 of risk capital (GOV.UK, 2026). The bank should still treat that equity as unconfirmed until it is paid in.
(e) Presentation, research and recommendation
Present the report as a lending memorandum: executive summary with a clear decision, sections matching the five questions, and appendices holding the cash flow, ratios and sensitivity workings. The review of theory should show why a framework such as CAMPARI is used and how relationship lending relies on information that is hard to verify for new firms. Hull (2023) is a useful source on credit risk assessment and the role of collateral in reducing loss given default.
The overall recommendation for this illustrative case is to approve the loan conditionally: release funds in stages once the £100,000 equity is committed, take a debenture and limited personal guarantee, and include a repayment profile that allows for slower early sales. Your own answer should follow the same logic with the actual case figures.
Related Westminster MSc finance samples include the 7FNCE028W wealth plan sample. For structuring the written appraisal, our report writing help page and the Westminster University assignment help page show what support is available.
Please Write Fresh Non Plagiarized Assignment on this Topic
References
Altman, E.I. (1968) ‘Financial ratios, discriminant analysis and the prediction of corporate bankruptcy’, The Journal of Finance, 23(4), pp. 589–609.
Berger, A.N. and Udell, G.F. (1990) ‘Collateral, loan quality and bank risk’, Journal of Monetary Economics, 25(1), pp. 21–42.
GOV.UK (2026) Apply to use the Enterprise Investment Scheme to raise money for your company. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/guidance/venture-capital-schemes-apply-for-the-enterprise-investment-scheme (Accessed: 16 November 2026).
Hull, J.C. (2023) Risk management and financial institutions. 6th edn. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
UPTO 35% DISCOUNT



